Inside IR35: what contractors and clients must check
IR35 is the tax rule contractors love to hate — and the one clients get sued over. Get it wrong and the tax bill can land years later, with interest. Yet the underlying test is simpler than the folklore suggests: are you, in reality, genuinely in business on your own account, or are you effectively an employee with an invoice? Here is how the rules work in 2026 and what both sides must actually check.
What IR35 is in one paragraph
IR35 exists to stop “disguised employment”: a worker who would be an employee if the contract were direct, supplying services through a limited company to enjoy a smaller tax bill. If a contract is inside IR35, tax and National Insurance must be paid broadly as if the worker were employed. If it is genuinely outside, the contractor’s own company pays Corporation Tax on profits and takes dividends. The status decision drives everything — which is why HMRC cares so much.
The three tests that decide your status
Every status assessment comes down to the same three factors. Ignore the job title and look at the reality:
- Control. Who directs how, when and where the work is done? A genuine business decides its own methods; an employee is told what to do and when.
- Substitution. Can you send someone else to do the work in your place? A real right of substitution — not just theoretical — points strongly to self-employment.
- Mutuality of obligation. Is the client obliged to offer work and are you obliged to accept it? An engagement that only exists when specific work is needed points to business-on-business.
Supporting factors matter too: who provides equipment, how you are paid, financial risk, whether you can profit from good management, and how the relationship looks to an outsider. No single factor decides a case — HMRC and the tribunals weigh the whole picture.
Who decides status — and when that changed
For work through medium and large private-sector clients (and all public-sector bodies), the client determines the contractor’s employment status for tax — a shift introduced in 2021 that moved the liability up the chain. Small private-sector clients are exempt: there, the contractor’s own company makes the assessment. Clients who get it wrong owe the unpaid tax and NICs, plus interest and potential penalties. Contractors working through their own company for a small client carry that responsibility themselves.
What contractors must check
- Which rules apply — ask whether the end client is small or medium/large; it changes who assesses status
- What the assessment says — clients must give you a Status Determination Statement (SDS) with reasons; a bare “inside IR35” verdict without reasoning is not compliant
- Whether the contract matches reality — a nicely written contract cannot rescue an engagement that operates like employment. HMRC looks at how the work actually runs
- Your option for a review — if you disagree with an SDS, you can ask the client to reconsider, and HMRC can also review determinations
What clients must check
- Take reasonable care in status assessments — careless assessments shift liability and can trigger penalties
- Issue proper SDS documents to each contractor with genuine reasoning, not boilerplate
- Keep assessments current — a status decided three years ago may not survive a changed working pattern
- Prepare for interest charge rules — off-payroll engagements have their own PAYE implications, including potential interest for clients who pay contractors net of a deemed deduction
The practical way to stay safe
Status is not a one-off box-tick; it is a property of the working relationship, and relationships drift. The safest pattern is simple: keep the engagement’s reality consistent with self-employment — project-based work, your own tools and methods, no open-ended obligation on either side — and document the assessment honestly. Where an engagement is clearly inside IR35, use the established compliant payment routes rather than hoping nobody notices.
Want this handled for you? Taxora helps contractors and clients handle IR35 and payroll compliance for a fixed monthly fee from £9.99 — talk to your dedicated accountant.
Quick answers
What does “inside IR35” actually mean for my take-home pay?
Inside IR35, income through your company is taxed broadly like employment: PAYE and NICs are applied to your deemed earnings, leaving materially less take-home than a genuine outside-IR35 engagement. That is why status matters so much financially.
Who decides my IR35 status?
For engagements with medium or large clients, the client does — and they owe the tax if they get it wrong. For small private-sector clients, you assess your own status. Ask which situation applies before you sign.
Can a written contract make me outside IR35?
Not on its own. The contract must reflect genuine self-employment terms, but HMRC examines how the engagement actually operates. Working like an employee while holding a self-employed-looking contract is the classic route to an HMRC challenge.
What is a Status Determination Statement?
A document the client must provide setting out its status conclusion and the reasons behind it. Contractors can request a review if they disagree, and a determination without reasonable care shifts the liability back to the fee-payer.
Can HMRC look at old contracts?
Yes. Status can be examined for past years, and retrospective bills — with interest — are exactly what makes IR35 expensive. That is why current, well-reasoned assessments are worth maintaining.
This article is general information for UK contractors and businesses and is not financial or tax advice. IR35 rules are technical and fact-specific; take professional advice on your own arrangements.
Read more: see our services and prices, or get in touch for a free chat about your status.
