Company car or cash allowance: the 2026/27 tax maths compared

Company car or cash allowance: the 2026/27 maths

Company car or cash allowance? In 2026/27 the answer has quietly changed for electric cars — and the numbers are closer than most owners assume. The right choice depends on the car’s CO2 figure, your tax band and what your company will actually pay you instead. Here is the honest arithmetic.

How a company car is taxed in 2026/27

If your limited company provides a car you use privately, you pay income tax on a benefit in kind (BIK). The calculation is simple in shape:

  • Car value: the list price including VAT and delivery charges, plus optional extras fitted before delivery (the “P11D value”).
  • Appropriate percentage: a percentage set by the car’s CO2 emissions and, for electric and plug-in hybrids, its electric range.
  • Your tax bill: P11D value × appropriate percentage × your income tax rate.

For 2026/27 the percentages for the greenest cars have risen again. A pure electric car now sits at 4% (up from 3% in 2025/26), cars between 1–50g/km CO2 have risen by one percentage point in each band, while conventional cars of 75g/km and above are frozen at their 2025/26 levels. The maximum is 37%, and diesels attract a 4% supplement unless they meet the latest emissions standards. The full table is in HMRC’s company car guidance (480 Appendix 2) on gov.uk.

Insight: the tax system rewards low emissions with brutal consistency — a petrol car at 160g/km carries a 37% BIK percentage; an electric car carries 4%. On the same £40,000 list price, that is the difference between a £14,800 and a £1,600 annual taxable benefit.

Worked example: the £40,000 car

Take a £40,000 list price and a higher-rate taxpayer paying 40% income tax:

  • Electric car (4%): £40,000 × 4% = £1,600 taxable benefit × 40% = £640 a year in tax. The company also pays employer’s National Insurance at 13.8% on the £1,600 benefit: about £221.
  • Petrol car at 160g/km (37%): £40,000 × 37% = £14,800 × 40% = £5,920 a year. Employer’s NIC adds roughly £2,042. Most owners of a car like this genuinely should not run it through the company in 2026/27.

That £5,000+ swing is why the CO2 figure on the spec sheet matters more than the badge on the bonnet. Always check the WLTP CO2 figure and, for hybrids, the official electric range before you sign anything.

What a cash allowance actually costs you

The alternative is a cash allowance added to your salary instead of a car. Three things follow:

  • It is taxed as salary. Income tax at your marginal rate plus both employee’s and employer’s National Insurance. Unlike BIK, there is no CO2 discount — £6,000 of allowance costs a higher-rate earner roughly £3,480 in employee tax and NI, before the company’s own NIC on top.
  • You own the car. You buy or lease it personally and reclaim nothing for business miles beyond HMRC’s approved mileage allowance (45p per mile for the first 10,000 business miles).
  • The company saves money. No employer’s NIC on a BIK benefit and no car on the balance sheet — which is why many companies prefer to offer allowances.

For electric cars, the maths now often favours the company car: the BIK charge is so low that even after employer’s NIC, the company route beats a salary-taxed allowance for many drivers. For petrol cars, the opposite is usually true — take the allowance, buy personally, and use mileage claims for business trips.

The questions that decide it

  1. What is the car’s official CO2 figure (and electric range if it is a hybrid)? This single number drives the entire BIK calculation.
  2. What is your marginal income tax rate? 20%, 40% or 45% — the BIK charge scales directly.
  3. How many genuine business miles will you do? Under a personal car with a cash allowance, you claim per mile; under a company car, the running costs are largely the company’s problem.
  4. Who pays for insurance, servicing and charging? In the company car column, usually the company.
  5. What happens at the end? A company car is handed back; a personal car is yours to sell, with the depreciation risk that implies.

Your choice is not locked forever either. You can typically change car or switch to an allowance at renewal, or by varying your remuneration package — but run the numbers each tax year, because the percentages move: EVs rise to 5% in 2027/28 and keep climbing on the published schedule.

Running a car through a limited company interacts with directors’ salaries, dividends and corporation tax — our limited company accountancy service covers all of it as part of one monthly fee.

Want this handled for you? Taxora handles limited company tax and benefits planning for a fixed monthly fee from £9.99 — talk to your dedicated accountant.

Quick answers

What is the benefit in kind rate for an electric company car in 2026/27?

4% of the car’s P11D value — up from 3% in 2025/26. It rises to 5% in 2027/28. For a £40,000 EV, a higher-rate taxpayer pays £640 a year in company car tax.

How is a company car tax bill calculated?

P11D value (list price plus VAT, delivery and pre-delivery extras) × the appropriate percentage for the car’s CO2 emissions × your income tax rate. Employer’s National Insurance at 13.8% is also due on the taxable benefit.

Is a cash allowance better than a company car?

For petrol or diesel cars, usually yes — the cash allowance avoids the high BIK charge, though it is taxed as salary. For electric cars, the low 4% BIK rate often makes the company car route cheaper overall. Compare both with real numbers for your car and tax band.

Do I still pay tax on a company car if I only drive it for business?

If the car is available for private use — even just commuting — the benefit applies. Availability is what triggers the charge, not actual private mileage. Genuinely business-only cars kept at the business premises can avoid the charge, but that is a high bar for most owner-managers.

Are the company car tax rates changing again?

Yes. Electric and low-emission rates rise by one percentage point in 2027/28 and continue rising on a published schedule, while rates for cars of 75g/km CO2 and above are frozen until April 2028. Check the figures for the tax year you will actually own the car.

This article is general information for UK small businesses and individuals and is not financial or tax advice. Figures and rules can change; check gov.uk or speak to an accountant about your specific circumstances.

Read more: see our services and prices, or get in touch for a free chat about your year ahead.

Leave a Reply