Hiring Your First Employee? The PAYE, Payslip and Pension Checklist (2026/27)

Taking on your first employee is a milestone — demand has outgrown one pair of hands. It also turns you into an employer overnight, with a short list of legal duties: register with HMRC, pay at least the minimum wage, give proper payslips and enrol your hire in a pension. None of it is difficult, but order matters and deadlines are unforgiving. This week’s tax tip is the honest checklist, in the order you’ll need it.

Before the first payday: register, check, insure

Three things must be in place before your new hire clocks in:

  • Register as an employer with HMRC. Register before the first payday to get your employer PAYE reference number — and you can’t register more than 2 months before you start paying people, so the sweet spot is 4 to 8 weeks before day one.
  • Check the right to work. Every employer must check the right to work before someone starts. Get it wrong and the civil penalty can reach up to £60,000 per illegal worker — though you won’t pay a penalty if you can show you made the correct checks. The Home Office online service is free and takes minutes.
  • Buy employers’ liability insurance. As soon as you become an employer you need at least £5 million of cover from an authorised insurer — and you can be fined £2,500 for every day you’re not properly insured.

Your PAYE reference arrives by post; if you pay someone before the letter lands, HMRC’s guidance lets you run payroll and keep the records anyway.

Set the pay — and know the 2026/27 rates

You can’t pay below the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage — and rates rose again on 1 April 2026. This year the minimums are £12.71 an hour for those aged 21 and over, £10.85 for 18 to 20-year-olds, and £8.00 for under-18s and apprentices. Rates change every April, so check gov.uk before you agree a salary or hourly rate.

No P45 from a previous job? Complete a starter checklist in your payroll — it sets the right tax code from week one.

Running payroll: report on time, payslip properly, keep records

From the first payday, every employee — even a part-timer — must be reported to HMRC in real time: payroll software (or an accountant) submits a full payment submission on or before each payday, and you pay HMRC by your deadline.

Each payday, your employee must receive a payslip on or before pay day showing earnings before and after deductions, each deduction such as tax and National Insurance, and hours if pay varies by time worked. And keep the paperwork: payroll records must be kept for 3 years from the end of the tax year they relate to — HMRC can check them to make sure you’ve reported accurately.

The pension duty most first-time employers miss

Automatic enrolment isn’t optional — or just for big firms. If your employee is eligible — generally aged 22 or over, up to State Pension age, working in the UK and earning £10,000+ a year — you must enrol them in a qualifying pension scheme and pay in too. The minimum contribution is 8% of qualifying earnings, with at least 3% from you as the employer — stable since April 2019.

You must then tell The Pensions Regulator you’ve complied within five months of your duties start date. Younger or lower-earning staff aren’t automatically enrolled, but they can ask to join and you must assess and record it. It’s a rolling duty: every three years you re-enrol eligible staff, even if they opted out.

The surprise: employer National Insurance costs less than you think

Here’s the bit that puts first-time employers at ease. In 2026/27, employer Class 1 National Insurance is charged at 15% — but only above a secondary threshold of £5,000 a year (£96 a week, £417 a month). Better still, the Employment Allowance lets eligible employers cut their annual employer NI bill by up to £10,500 — claimed through your payroll (an Employment Payment Summary), and it can even cover previous tax years.

Work an example: an employee on £25,000 generates around £3,000 of employer National Insurance ((£25,000 − £5,000) × 15%). For most eligible small employers the Allowance wipes that out entirely. Some employers are excluded — for example, businesses doing more than half their work in the public sector — so confirm eligibility first.

The tax system is quietly kind to first-time employers: with a £5,000 threshold before employer NI bites and £10,500 of Employment Allowance, many small employers pay £0 employer NI on their first hire — but only if the allowance is claimed.

Quick answers

Do I need to register for PAYE if I only employ one part-timer?

Yes. You must register before the first payday even for one person working a few hours a week. Depending on pay, they may owe little or no tax and NI — but you still report through payroll.

How much does an employee cost beyond their salary?

Budget for employer National Insurance (15% of pay above £5,000 in 2026/27) and a 3% pension contribution for eligible staff. The Employment Allowance — up to £10,500 off employer NI — often removes the NI cost entirely for a first hire.

Can I pay my first employee in cash and skip payroll?

No. Cash pay is still pay — it must be registered, reported and taxed through PAYE. Paying “off the books” risks penalties and back-tax, and your employee loses pension contributions and proof of income.

What happens if I register as an employer late?

HMRC can charge penalties for late registration, on top of any tax and NI owed. If you’ve already paid someone and haven’t registered, do it straight away — coming forward promptly is cheaper than waiting to be caught.

Do I have to enrol an employee who’s under 22 into a pension?

Not automatically — but they can ask to join, and if they do you must enrol them and pay your share. Every employee must be assessed and the assessment recorded, whatever their age or earnings.

Getting your first hire right sets the tone for every hire after. At Taxora, a dedicated personal accountant can run payroll, RTI and auto-enrolment for you, claim your Employment Allowance and keep every deadline handled — with fixed monthly fees from £9.99 and unlimited support. Talk to our team today, or see our services.

This article is general information about employing staff in the UK and does not constitute financial, tax or accounting advice. Rates and thresholds can change; check gov.uk or speak to a qualified accountant about your specific circumstances.